Nagios vs Zabbix vs Icinga vs OP5

1. Nagios – Network Monitoring Software

Nagios System Monitoring Tools for LinuxNagios won by a huge margin. This is not a suprise to lot of people, as Nagios is hands-down the best monitoring tool. As you already know, I love Nagios and have been using it for a long time.

2. Cacti – Network Monitoring Software

Cacti Network Monitoring Tool for UnixCacti uses RRDtool for the network graphing solution. Using Caci you can monitor and graph – CPU Load, Network bandwidth utilization, network traffic monitor etc.,

Cacti also supports plugin architecture. Some admins like the powerful graphing feature provided by Cacti, they use both Nagios and Cacti in their environment as the network monitoring tools.

3. Top (and other top variations)

Unix top, ntop command for Network Monitoring

  • Top Command – Few of you have mentioned top command as your favorite monitoring tool
  • ntop (Network Top) – Ntop is a free network monitoring software. ntop displays network usage information in a similar fashion to top command output. You can also create HTML output file (dump) of the network status using ntop. Apart from the command line, you can also launch the web version of the ntop once you’ve started the ntopd service and visit http://{ip-address}:3000 from browser.
  • htop (interactive process viewer for Linux) – htop is similar to top command with few additional features. The main difference is that you can use mouse to interact with the htop command output.

4. Zabbix

Zabbix Open Source Infrastructure Monitoring Solution for Unix Platforms Zabbiz is an open source monitoring solution with a commercial support provided by a company – Zabbix SIA, who primarily develops the software. Zabbix requires a database to store the monitoring data. You can choose any DB of your choice – MySQL, PostgreSQL, Oracle, or SQLite.

Zabbix has the following three main modules:

  • Server (written in C)
  • Agents (written in C)
  • Frontend (PHP and Javascript)

Additional information about Zabbix:

5. Munin

Munin Network Badwidth Monitoring Platform Using PluginsSimilar to Cacti, Munin uses RRDTool to present the output in a pretty graph via web interface. The primary emphasis of Munin is on the plug and play architecture for it’s plugin. There are lot of plugins available for Munin, which will just work out-of-the box without lot of tweaking.

Comments

  1. Eric Maydon says:

    Trying to find the result of your test Nagios vs Icinga vs Op5. Dont find the test, only one line. We using Op5 and its not close to Nagios since they added so much more. So , would be great if you could show your result.

    Thanks, eric

  2. fact that u put zabbix at a 4th place and nagios at 1 only shows that u dont know anything about the software. Zabbix wins by lenghts from nagios it cant even come close many of the features tha nagios has to rely on 3rd party are already in zabbix.

  3. hmm where is the topic??

Leave a Reply